Compare Motors Side by Side

Last verified: 2026-11-02

Verifiable indicators

Short-time duty (S2) — Wistar motor WSEC50 · 10 Nm · 21 rpm: 4 min^{[1; 2026-10-02]}; Nice Era Inn Action E ACTION MI 1020 AC: 6 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]}; Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: 6 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]}; Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline SuperSilent · 10 Nm · 17 rpm: 4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}.

Rated life — Wistar motor WSEC50 · 10 Nm · 21 rpm: Not published. Nice Era Inn Action E ACTION MI 1020 AC: Not published. Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Not yet collected. Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline SuperSilent · 10 Nm · 17 rpm: Not published.

Thermal protection — Wistar motor WSEC50 · 10 Nm · 21 rpm: Not published. Nice Era Inn Action E ACTION MI 1020 AC: Not published. Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Not yet collected. Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline SuperSilent · 10 Nm · 17 rpm: Not published.

IP rating — Wistar motor WSEC50 · 10 Nm · 21 rpm: IP44^{[7; 2026-10-06]}; Nice Era Inn Action E ACTION MI 1020 AC: IP30^{[4; 2026-10-01]}; Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: IP30^{[4; 2026-10-01]}; Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline SuperSilent · 10 Nm · 17 rpm: IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}.

Comparison table
Property	Wistar motor WSEC50 · 10 Nm · 21 rpmWistar motorWSEC50-10/21	Nice Era Inn Action E ACTION MI 1020 ACNiceE ACTION MI 1020 AC	Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BDNiceE EDGE MI 1020 AC BD	Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline SuperSilent · 10 Nm · 17 rpmGeiger AntriebstechnikGB45SS- 10/17
Series & variant axes
SeriesDiffers: WSEC50 vs Era Inn Action M vs Era Inn Edge M BD vs PRO.TECline SuperSilent	WSEC50	Era Inn Action M	Era Inn Edge M BD	PRO.TECline SuperSilent
Identity & lineage
Series / product lineDiffers: WSEC50^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs Not published vs — vs PRO.TECline SuperSilent^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	WSEC50^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	Not published	—	PRO.TECline SuperSilent^{[2; 2026-10-01]}
Electrical
Rated voltage	230 V^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	Not published	—	230 V^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Supply voltage (min)	Not published	100 V^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	100 V^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Supply voltage (max)	Not published	240 V^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	240 V^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Mains frequencyDiffers: 60 Hz^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 50 Hz, 60 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 50 Hz, 60 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 50 Hz^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	60 Hz^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	50 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}, 60 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	50 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}, 60 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	50 Hz^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Power supply type	AC mains^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	AC mains^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	AC mains^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	AC mains^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Supply rating (as stated)	Not published	Not published	—	230 V~/50 Hz^{[2; 2026-09-23]}
Rated power inputDiffers: 132 W^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 70 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 70 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 120 W^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	132 W^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	70 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	70 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	120 W^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Standby power	Not published	< 0.5 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	< 0.5 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Rated currentDiffers: 0.58 A^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 1.1 A^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 1.1 A^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 0.54 A^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	0.58 A^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	1.1 A^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	1.1 A^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	0.54 A^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Power factor (cos φ)	Not published	Not published	—	> 0.95 ^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Inrush current factor	Not published	Not published	—	1.2 x^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Cable connection	Not published	Not published	—	Fixed cable^{[2; 2026-10-01]}
Drive performance
Rated torque	10 Nm^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	10 Nm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	10 Nm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	10 Nm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Rated speedDiffers: 21 rpm^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 20 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 20 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 17 rpm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	21 rpm^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	20 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	20 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	17 rpm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Speed range (min)	Not published	Not published	10 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Speed range (max)	Not published	Not published	32 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Short-time duty (S2)Differs: 4 min^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 6 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 6 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	4 min^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	6 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Highest stated	6 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Highest stated	4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Duty type	Not published	Not published	—	S2^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Max load	Not published	29 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	29 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Dimensions & mounting
Motor diameter	45 mm^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	45 mm^{[5; 2026-10-09]}	45 mm^{[5; 2026-10-09]}	45 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
Fits tube diameter	Not published	≥ 45 mm^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	—	Not published
Overall lengthDiffers: 570 mm^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 759 mm^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 759 mm^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 598 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	570 mm^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	759 mm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	759 mm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	598 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}
WeightDifferent basis: 2.05 kg^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs 2.1 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 2.1 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs ≈ 2.5 kg^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	2.05 kg^{[1; 2026-10-02]}Different basis	2.1 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	2.1 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	≈ 2.5 kg^{[3; 2026-10-01]}Different basis
Limits & protection
Limit settingDiffers: Mechanical^{[1; 2026-10-02]} vs Electronic^{[6; 2026-10-01]} vs — vs Mechanical^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	Mechanical^{[1; 2026-10-02]}	Electronic^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	—	Mechanical^{[2; 2026-10-01]}
Limit rangeDifferent basis: — vs < 150 turns^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs < 150 turns^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs 22 turns^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	—	< 150 turns^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	< 150 turns^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	22 turns^{[3; 2026-10-01]}Different basis
Obstacle detection	Not published	Not published	—	No^{[2; 2026-10-01]}
Control & communication
Control interface (as stated)	Not published	Hardwired^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	—	Not published
Environment & protection
IP ratingDiffers: IP44^{[7; 2026-10-06]} vs IP30^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs IP30^{[4; 2026-10-01]} vs IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	IP44^{[7; 2026-10-06]}Highest stated	IP30^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	IP30^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}Highest stated
Operating temp. (min)	Not published	0 °C^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	0 °C^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Operating temp. (max)	Not published	60 °C^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	60 °C^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Noise levelDiffers: Not published vs 33 dB(A)^{[4; 2026-11-02]} vs 33 dB(A)^{[4; 2026-11-02]} vs 30 dB(A)^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	Not published	33 dB(A)^{[4; 2026-11-02]}	33 dB(A)^{[4; 2026-11-02]}	30 dB(A)^{[3; 2026-10-01]}Lowest stated
Application
ApplicationsDiffers: Not published vs Roller blind, Screen^{[6; 2026-10-05]}^{[6; 2026-10-01]} vs — vs Awning, Roller shutter, Screen^{[2; 2026-10-01]}^{[2; 2026-10-01]}^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	Not published	Roller blind^{[6; 2026-10-05]}, Screen^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	—	Awning^{[2; 2026-10-01]}, Roller shutter^{[2; 2026-10-01]}, Screen^{[2; 2026-10-01]}
Documents	Request datasheet	Request datasheet	Request datasheet	Request datasheet

— means no value: the manufacturer does not publish it, it does not apply to this product type, or there is none on record. Value states

Data gaps

Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Series / product line — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Rated voltage — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Cable connection — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Cable length — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Fits tube diameter — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Limit setting — Not yet collected
Wistar motor WSEC50 · 10 Nm · 21 rpm: Limit range — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Control protocol — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Radio frequency — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Two-way feedback — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Applications — Not yet collected
Nice Era Inn Edge BD E EDGE MI 1020 AC BD: Marks stated by vendor — Not yet collected

Sources

↑Wistar motor manufacturer site (product catalog)wistarmotor.comSeries / product line: Ref: WSEC50Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-02 · Retrieved 2026-10-01 · Public web pageUsed for: 44912, 44906, 44911, 44901, 44905, 44907, 44899, 44900, 44908, 44903, 44909, 44910, 44913
↑Geiger Antriebstechnik manufacturer site (product catalog)geiger.deSeries / product line: PRO.TECline SuperSilentManufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-09-23 · Public web pageUsed for: 6988, 1158, 6994, 6993, 6992, 6991, 6989, 6990
↑Geiger Antriebstechnik PDF cataloguegeiger.deRated voltage: Spannung: 230V~/50 Hz [GB45SS-10/17] (p. 27)Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-10-01 · Public web pageUsed for: 30611, 30616, 30614, 30623, 30617, 30619, 30621, 30625, 30627, 30635, 30637, 30641, 30633, 30643, 30629, 30631, 30639
↑Nice S.p.A. PDF catalogueniceforyou.comSupply voltage (min): Power supply (Vac/Hz): 100-240 / 50-60 [E ACTION MI 1020 AC] (p. 85)Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-10-01 · Public web pageUsed for: 38354, 38478, 38355, 38479, 38357, 38358, 38481, 38482, 38356, 38480, 38360, 38484, 38361, 38485, 38359, 38483, 38362, 38486, 38363, 38487, 38489, 38488, 38366, 38492, 38367, 38493, 38368, 38494, 38369, 38495, 38365, 38491, 38372, 38498, 38370, 38496, 38371, 38497, 67995, 68001
↑Tubular diameter derivation tdia-nice-era-size-v1niceforyou.com[tdia-nice-era-size-v1] Ø 45 mm from "E ACTION MI 1020". Nice Era Star T manual §3.1: motors that are size "S" (Ø = 35 mm) … size "M" (Ø = 45 mm) … size "L" (Ø = 58 mm). Nice Sun Shading catalogue 2026 p70: "ERA INN S Ø 35 mm", "ERA INN M Ø 45 mm".Derived (model name) · Observed 2026-10-09 · Retrieved 2026-10-09 · Public web pageUsed for: 54449, 54455
↑Elero manufacturer site (product catalog)elero.comFits tube (min.): Shaft size (mm) from 45Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-09-23 · Public web pageUsed for: 46022, 46021, 46019, 48968, 46020
↑Wistar motor PDF catalogue WSEC40-WSEC50wistarmotor.comIP rating: Protection index: IP44 (p. 1)Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-06 · Retrieved 2026-10-06 · Public web pageUsed for: 49870

See something wrong? Report an error

Compare motors

Verifiable indicators

Data gaps

Sources