Compare Motors Side by Side

Last verified: 2026-11-05

Verifiable indicators

Short-time duty (S2) — Elero RolTop/D+ M SH · 30 Nm · 14 rpm: 4 min^{[2; 2026-10-01]}; Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle NHK · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: 4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}; Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: 4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}; Nice 230 Vac E M 3017: 4 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]}.

Rated life — Elero RolTop/D+ M SH · 30 Nm · 14 rpm: Not published. Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle NHK · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: Not published. Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: Not published. Nice 230 Vac E M 3017: Not published.

Thermal protection — Elero RolTop/D+ M SH · 30 Nm · 14 rpm: Not published. Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle NHK · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: Not published. Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: Not published. Nice 230 Vac E M 3017: Not published.

IP rating — Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle NHK · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}; Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle · 30 Nm · 15 rpm: IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}; Nice 230 Vac E M 3017: IP44^{[4; 2026-10-01]}. Elero RolTop/D+ M SH · 30 Nm · 14 rpm: Not published.

Comparison table
Property	Elero RolTop/D+ M SH · 30 Nm · 14 rpmElero39 043.0001	Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle NHK · 30 Nm · 15 rpmGeiger AntriebstechnikGB45M- 30/15	Geiger Antriebstechnik PRO.TECline Spindle · 30 Nm · 15 rpmGeiger AntriebstechnikGB45S- 30/15	Nice 230 Vac E M 3017NiceE M 3017
Series & variant axes
SeriesDiffers: RolTop/D+ M SH vs PRO.TECline Spindle NHK vs PRO.TECline Spindle vs Era M	RolTop/D+ M SH	PRO.TECline Spindle NHK	PRO.TECline Spindle	Era M
Identity & lineage
Series / product lineDiffers: Not published vs PRO.TECline Spindle NHK^{[1; 2026-10-01]} vs PRO.TECline Spindle^{[1; 2026-10-01]} vs Not published	Not published	PRO.TECline Spindle NHK^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	PRO.TECline Spindle^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Electrical
Rated voltage	230 V^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	230 V^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	230 V^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	230 V^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Mains frequency	50 Hz^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	50 Hz^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	50 Hz^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	50 Hz^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Power supply type	AC mains^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	AC mains^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	AC mains^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	AC mains^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Supply rating (as stated)	Not published	230 V~/50 Hz^{[1; 2026-09-23]}	230 V~/50 Hz^{[1; 2026-09-23]}	Not published
Rated power inputDiffers: 200 W^{[2; 2026-10-01]} vs 180 W^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 180 W^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 250 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	200 W^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	180 W^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	180 W^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	250 W^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Rated currentDiffers: 0.9 A^{[2; 2026-10-01]} vs 0.8 A^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 0.8 A^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 1.1 A^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	0.9 A^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	0.8 A^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	0.8 A^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	1.1 A^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Power factor (cos φ)	Not published	> 0.95 ^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	> 0.95 ^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Inrush current factor	Not published	1.2 x^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	1.2 x^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Cable connection	Not published	Fixed cable^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Fixed cable^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Cable length	Not published	Not published	Not published	2.5 m^{[5; 2026-11-05]}
Drive performance
Rated torque	30 Nm^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	30 Nm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	30 Nm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	30 Nm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Rated speedDiffers: 14 rpm^{[2; 2026-10-01]} vs 15 rpm^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 15 rpm^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 17 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	14 rpm^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	15 rpm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	15 rpm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	17 rpm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Short-time duty (S2)	4 min^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	4 min^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	4 min^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Duty type	S2^{[2; 2026-10-01]}	S2^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	S2^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Max load	Not published	Not published	Not published	56 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Dimensions & mounting
Motor diameter	Not published	45 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	45 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	45 mm^{[5; 2026-10-07]}
Fits tube diameter	≥ 50 mm^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	Not published	Not published	Not published
Overall lengthDiffers: Not published vs 568 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 488 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 486 mm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published	568 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	488 mm^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	486 mm^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
WeightDifferent basis: 2.3 kg^{[2; 2026-10-01]} vs ≈ 2.5 kg^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs ≈ 2.2 kg^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 2.45 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	2.3 kg^{[2; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	≈ 2.5 kg^{[3; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	≈ 2.2 kg^{[3; 2026-10-01]}Different basis	2.45 kg^{[4; 2026-10-01]}Different basis
Limits & protection
Limit settingDiffers: Electronic^{[6; 2026-10-01]} vs Mechanical^{[1; 2026-10-01]} vs Mechanical^{[1; 2026-10-01]} vs Mechanical^{[5; 2026-10-07]}	Electronic^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	Mechanical^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Mechanical^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Mechanical^{[5; 2026-10-07]}
Limit rangeDiffers: Not published vs 22 turns^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 22 turns^{[3; 2026-10-01]} vs 27 turns^{[4; 2026-10-01]}	Not published	22 turns^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	22 turns^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	27 turns^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Obstacle detection	Not published	No^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	No^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Control & communication
Control interface (as stated)	Hardwired^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	Not published	Not published	Not published
Radio frequency	Not published	Not published	Not published	50 MHz^{[5; 2026-11-05]}
Environment & protection
IP rating	Not published	IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	IP44^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	IP44^{[4; 2026-10-01]}
Noise level	Not published	39 dB(A)^{[1; 2026-09-23]}	39 dB(A)^{[3; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Application
ApplicationsDiffers: Roller shutter^{[6; 2026-10-01]} vs Awning, Cassette awning, Roller shutter, Screen^{[1; 2026-10-01]}^{[1; 2026-10-01]}^{[1; 2026-10-01]}^{[1; 2026-10-01]} vs Awning, Cassette awning, Roller shutter, Screen^{[1; 2026-10-01]}^{[1; 2026-10-02]}^{[1; 2026-10-01]}^{[1; 2026-10-01]} vs Not published	Roller shutter^{[6; 2026-10-01]}	Awning^{[1; 2026-10-01]}, Cassette awning^{[1; 2026-10-01]}, Roller shutter^{[1; 2026-10-01]}, Screen^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Awning^{[1; 2026-10-01]}, Cassette awning^{[1; 2026-10-02]}, Roller shutter^{[1; 2026-10-01]}, Screen^{[1; 2026-10-01]}	Not published
Compliance & declarations
Marks stated by vendor	Not published	Not published	Not published	CE^{[5; 2026-11-05]}, NF^{[5; 2026-11-05]}
Documents	Request datasheet	Request datasheet	Request datasheet	Request datasheet

Sources

↑Geiger Antriebstechnik manufacturer site (product catalog)geiger.deSeries / product line: PRO.TECline Spindle NHKManufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-09-23 · Public web pageUsed for: 7077, 5410, 1188, 633, 7084, 5417, 7083, 5416, 7082, 5415, 1190, 7080, 7081, 7078, 7079, 6716, 45823, 5411, 5412
↑Elero GmbH PDF catalogue elero_Catalog_2026_oP_08-26_EN.pdf (Title)elero.comRated voltage: Rated voltage (V): 1 ~ 230 [390430001] (p. 56)Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-10-01 · Public web pageUsed for: 33497, 33499, 33498, 33501, 33500, 33495, 33496, 33502, 33503, 33504
↑Geiger Antriebstechnik PDF cataloguegeiger.deRated voltage: Spannung: 230V~/50 Hz [GB45M-30/15] (p. 31)Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-10-01 · Public web pageUsed for: 30783, 30369, 30787, 30373, 30785, 30371, 30795, 30382, 30789, 30375, 30790, 30378, 30793, 30380, 30797, 30384, 30799, 30386, 30807, 30394, 30809, 30396, 30811, 30400, 30805, 30392, 30813, 30402, 30801, 30388, 30803, 30390, 30398
↑Nice S.p.A. PDF catalogueniceforyou.comRated voltage: Power supply (Vac/Hz): 230/50 [E M 3017] (p. 116)Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-10-01 · Public web pageUsed for: 38983, 38985, 38984, 38987, 38986, 38988, 38989, 38992, 38990, 38993, 38994, 38991, 38995
↑Nice manufacturer site (product catalog)niceforyou.comCable length: Lunghezza del cavo di alimentazione 2,5 mManufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-11-05 · Retrieved 2026-09-23 · Public web pageUsed for: 69727, 51589, 51591, 69723, 69725, 69726
↑Elero manufacturer site (product catalog)elero.comFits tube (min.): Shaft size (mm) from 50Manufacturer-stated · Observed 2026-10-01 · Retrieved 2026-09-23 · Public web pageUsed for: 27056, 27055, 27053, 27054

See something wrong? Report an error

Compare motors

Verifiable indicators

Sources